DIEGESIS MAGAZINE
  • Home
    • About >
      • Like Us!
      • Join in >
        • Subscribe
        • Pitch
      • Contact Us
  • Print Issues
    • ALL
    • BEGINNING
    • END
    • I.D./CONTROL >
      • I.D.
      • CONTROL
    • COMPILATION
    • Conflict >
      • Conflict writers
    • Waste
  • Mini Issues
    • DECADE
    • RESET
    • 7 Deadly Sins >
      • SLOTH Mar 2020
      • WRATH FEB 2020
      • GREED JULY 2018
      • PRIDE JUNE 2018
      • ENVY MARCH 2018
      • GLUTTONY JANUARY 2018
      • LUST DECEMBER 2017
    • Personal August 2017
    • Short July 2017
    • Reality May 2017
    • Noise April 2017
    • Journey Mar 2017
    • Accolade Feb 2017
    • Fresh Starts and Finales Jan 2017
    • Emotional Summer 2016 >
      • LOVE
      • ANGER
      • SADNESS
      • SURPRISE
      • JOY
      • FEAR
  • Archive
    • Reviews
    • Interviews
    • Festivals
    • Articles
  • Blog
    • MUBIVIEWS
DIEGESIS : THE UNCONVENTIONAL MAGAZINE OF FILM AND TELEVISION CRITICISM
watch / read / discuss

MUBIVIEWS

    join the discussion
    sign up for film announcements and new blog alerts
Notify Me
Picture

MUBIVIEWS: SILENCE [day five]

14/4/2017

1 Comment

 

curator's note

This week, our writers discuss a film that speaks quietly to its audience and requires the recognition of the quiet intensity of the narrative. SILENCE (Pat Collins 2012) is about a sound recordist, Eoghan (Eoghan Mac Giolla Bhride), who returns to Ireland after 15 years of living in Germany to record areas free of man-made sound. During his quest, he is influenced by folklore and a series of challenging encounters that reflect the intangible silence of his childhood. The film celebrates the beautifully poetic landscape of Ireland and the stories it has to tell.

LISTENING OUT FOR HOME

GEORGE LEE

Picture
In the film SILENCE (Pat Collins 2012), Eoghan is tasked with returning to his Irish homeland - after being away 15 years - to record sounds free from man-made noise. The purpose of his labour is not disclosed, only that he has been employed to do so. To achieve silence, however, seems futile.

To be able to record noises truly free of any man-made sound is unfeasible as, to be able to record sound in general, it requires the use of a man-made machine which in turn makes a sound. Even the most minimal hum of a battery pack prevents silence from being achieved. At one point a man stumbles upon Eoghan and asks "So you’re here?" and Eoghan replies "I am here yeah, but I’m keeping quiet". This conversation seems reminiscent of the old thought experiment: "If a tree falls in the forest and no one is there to hear it, does it make a sound?" Ergo, if Eoghan is there to record it then his presence will prevent the goal of silence. 


Eoghan seemingly knows that recording silence is impossible, which therefore raises the question of why is he doing it? Or if he really is being employed to do it, what is the purpose of his employer? It seems that this quest for silence is simply an unexplained plot device in order for Eoghan to return home and face his past, as his new life in Berlin acts as an escape from his vague but painful memories of Ireland. Eoghan returning to his homeland is significant as he becomes the tree from the thought experiment. If he is not physically in Ireland, does it continue to exist without his presence? What he slowly learns through the film is that life continues, regardless of if he is there to witness it.

Every day this week a different writer will provide their perspective on our MUBIVIEWS film and each post will be open to comments from our readers. Watch SILENCE on mubi.com until 26 April 2017 and join the discussion!
1 Comment
Em Houghton
14/4/2017 05:05:23 pm

You're totally correct in your argument, recording "silence" is impossible. Silence itself does not exist, as it means the total lack of sound. In addition to this, Sound recordists often have to act "the invisible man" during recording or filming, as any noise they make will be picked up; it offers a philosophical look towards how Eoghan himself might be feeling invisible.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    MUBIVIEWS

    One MUBI film, five perspectives, endless possibilities.

    Archives

    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017

    Categories

    All
    Adolescence
    Alice In Wonderland
    Audience
    Battle Royale
    Childhood
    Class
    Comedy
    Coming-of-age
    Contact High
    Dialogue
    Disability
    Documentary
    Drugs
    Editing
    Gender
    Genre
    Identity
    Insanity
    Ireland
    Landscape
    La Rupture
    MacGuffin
    Mise En Scène
    Mise-en-scène
    Morals And Ethics
    Motherhood
    Narrative
    Nostalgia
    Opening Scene
    Scorsese
    Silence
    Social Realism
    Sound
    Sound Recording
    Taxi Driver
    The Boy From Geita
    Tomboy
    Violence
    Voyeurism
    Youth

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
    • About >
      • Like Us!
      • Join in >
        • Subscribe
        • Pitch
      • Contact Us
  • Print Issues
    • ALL
    • BEGINNING
    • END
    • I.D./CONTROL >
      • I.D.
      • CONTROL
    • COMPILATION
    • Conflict >
      • Conflict writers
    • Waste
  • Mini Issues
    • DECADE
    • RESET
    • 7 Deadly Sins >
      • SLOTH Mar 2020
      • WRATH FEB 2020
      • GREED JULY 2018
      • PRIDE JUNE 2018
      • ENVY MARCH 2018
      • GLUTTONY JANUARY 2018
      • LUST DECEMBER 2017
    • Personal August 2017
    • Short July 2017
    • Reality May 2017
    • Noise April 2017
    • Journey Mar 2017
    • Accolade Feb 2017
    • Fresh Starts and Finales Jan 2017
    • Emotional Summer 2016 >
      • LOVE
      • ANGER
      • SADNESS
      • SURPRISE
      • JOY
      • FEAR
  • Archive
    • Reviews
    • Interviews
    • Festivals
    • Articles
  • Blog
    • MUBIVIEWS